Dilemmas of the nationstate in the era of globalization 2000, the claims of culture. Negotiating republican selfdetermination and cosmopolitan norms by recalling this exchange between jaspers and arendt on the fate of eichmann. Using a case study of the emergence of the mexican indigenous rights movement, i argue that indigenous claims for autonomy and collective rights are not an expression of the universal human need for cultural recognition. Dilemmas of citizenship in contemporary europe the principles of discourse ethics require that all those affected by the consequences of the. Analyse a range of important political concepts including freedom, equality, justice, respect, recognition, toleration, and identity. In the words of terence turner such a view reductionist sociology of culture risks essentializing the idea of culture as the property o fan ethnic group or race. Maintaining that cultures are themselves torn by conflicts about their own boundaries, seyla benhabib challenges the assumption shared by. Seyla benhabib is the eugene meyer professor of political science and philosophy at yale university and was director of the program in ethics, politics and economics 20022008.
Benhabib concludes that flexible citizenship, certain kinds of legal pluralism and. An international journal of critical and democratic theory on deepdyve, the largest online rental service for scholarly research with thousands of academic publications available at your fingertips. Seyla benhabib was born in istanbul, turkey, where she received her ba in humanities at the american college for girls. Equality and diversity in the global era, benhabib examines different notions of multiculturalism. Nor do they reflect a retreat to the familiar realm of identity in the face of. The rights of others examines the boundaries of political community by focusing on political membership the principles and practices for. Because culture in this view is the precipitate of a common social lineage, the view is called the social lineage account of culture.
Though i have some minor personal qualms with professor benhabibs interpretation of arendt, i found the rights of others to be an amazing read that combined insightful interpretations of political thought with astute observations of our global situation. The case of contemporary europe in the midmorning hours of 11 september 2001, shortly after the second twin tower of the world trade center had collapsed, amidst the fog surrounding us all who, when, why i heard a brief item of news on the radio. This paper discusses multiculturalism in view of collectivistic cultural structures in immigrant. These claims range from demands for secession and sovereignty to assertion of. All content included on our site, such as text, images, digital downloads and other, is the property of its content suppliers and protected by us and international laws. Equality and diversity in the global era comments by katharina schramm benhabibs text links up very closely with recent and sometimes also not so recent debates in anthropology and related fields, as she is touching on the issues of culture and identity, globallocal dynamics, multiculturalism and. The rights of others examines the boundaries of political community by focusing on political membership the principles and practices for incorporating aliens and strangers, immigrants and newcomers, refugees and asylum seekers into existing polities. Seyla benhabib, wendell berry, and the question of migrant. The rights of others examines the boundaries of political community by focusing on political membership. If democracy is about managing inevitable power relations and preventing. Its reached the point that when you hear the word culture, you reach for your dictionary anthony appiah 2005, 114 every culture is a precipitate of history clyde kluckhohn. Rejecting the dismal view that the global world will be mired in the clash of civilizations and the culture wars, benhabib restores our faith in the human need to narrativize the historical and. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. As prelude to benhabibs deliberative democracy julia g.
The two contributions arise partly out of benhabibs understanding of political membership in liberal democracies as pivoting between claims for sovereign selfdetermination, on the one hand, and adherence to universal human rights principles on the other. The claims of culture was written against the background of a worldwide. Benhabib 2002, princeton university press, chapter six. Equality and diversity in the global era benhabib, seyla on. Human rights, sovereignty and democratic iterations lecture.
Seyla benhabib is the eugene meyer professor of political science and. Equality and diversity in the global era princeton and. Compare a range of arguments for and against multiculturalism. Equality and diversity in the global era by seyla benhabib princetonwoodstock. On the structure and domain of human rights practice mattias kumm1 there are three puzzling structural features of global human rights adjudication2 that have fostered scepticism about its philosophical respectability. The claims of culture offers invaluable insight to all those, whether students or scholars, lawyers or policymakers, who strive to bridge the gap between the theory and practice of cultural politics in the twentyfirst century.
Comments on seyla benhabib, the claims of culture deepdyve. Human rights global culture international institutions. Brooks university of pittsburgh introduction each semester during a discussion of socialization in my introductory sociology classes, i write on the board silenceagreement and invite students to discuss their initial responses to this statement. The eichmann trial, much like the nuremberg trials before it, captured some of the perplexities of the emerging norms of international and. Democracy and minority inclusion aalborg universitet. Its reached the point that when you hear the word culture, you reach for your dictionary anthony appiah 2005, 114 every culture is a.
Cosmopolitan democracy and the detention of immigrant. Aliens, residents, and citizens seyla benhabib, eugene meyer professor of political science and philosophy seyla benhabib cambridge university press, nov 25, 2004. The communicative ethics controversy free pdf, epub, fb3, rtf. Seyla benhabib, the generalized and the concrete other. Rejecting the dismal view that the global world will be mired in the clash of civilizations and the culture wars, benhabib restores our faith in the human need to narrativize the historical and cultural experiences of self and other.
The communicative ethics controversy by seyla benhabib editor in epub, fb3, rtf download ebook. A must read for those interested in global justice, cosmopolitanism and human rights theory. Aliens, residents and citizens 2004 which won the ralph bunche award of the american political science. She argues against the mosaic multiculturalism which considers different cultures as coexisting while remaining within firm borders, and insists. Her most recent publications include transformation of citizenship. Professor of economics department of economics new york university 19 west 4th street, 6th floor new york, ny 3 office.
Seyla benhabib phd, yale 1977 yale university, ct yu. Aug 25, 2002 a brave and beautiful book that grows in power and poignancy after 911. Rather, she argues, we must resolve the paradox of democratic legitimacy i. Princeton university press, 2002, paperback, 245 pp. Seyla benhabib s the claims of culture seeks the appropriate response in demo cratic theory to demands for differential legal or political treatment made in the name of cultural difference. How can liberal democracy best be realized in a world fraught.
Pdf on jun 1, 2006, seyla benhabib and others published the claims of culture find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. The rights of others seyla benhabib by lynnemarion issuu. Benhabib, seyla the tanner lectures on human values. A brave and beautiful book that grows in power and poignancy after 911. Human rights in troubled times, seyla benhabib cambridge, mass polity press, 2011, 288 pp.
Multiculturalism then appears not as a cultural liberator but as a cultural straitjacket, forcing those described as members of a. Describe the different rights claims and policy proposals that have been suggested by and on behalf of minority cultural communities. Jun 01, 2004 read comments on seyla benhabib, the claims of culture, constellations. The task of democratic equality is to create impartial institutions in the public sphere and civil society where the struggle for the recognition of cultural differences and contestation for cultural narratives can take place without domination. These claims range from demands for secession and sovereignty to assertion of novel rights, to claims for protection. Routing sustainability towards a culture of wellbeing. The claims of culture, equality and diversity in the global era, seyla benhabib 2002, princeton university press, chapter six. Equality and diversity in the global era and unni wikan, generous betrayal. The claims of culture was written against the background of a worldwide trend when cultural identities, and in particular cultural differences evolved. The claims of culture exploration culture, citizenship, and community.
All content included on our site, such as text, images, digital downloads and other, is the property of its content suppliers and protected by. By sean rehaag 2 in rights, benhabib takes on a pressing challenge facing contemporary theories of deliberative democracy. A contextual exploration of justice as evenhandedness download. Multiculturalism and pluralism in secular society chr. Equality and diversity in the global world 2002 and the rights of others. Though i have some minor personal qualms with professor benhabib s interpretation of arendt, i found the rights of others to be an amazing read that combined insightful interpretations of political thought with astute observations of our global situation. She then traveled to the united states, where she received her ba in philosophy at brandeis university and her ma and phd in philosophy at yale university. Identities, affiliations, and allegiances free pdf, chm. Routing sustainability towards a culture of wellbeing in its inception, during the 1970s, sustainable development was defined in relation to economic views and gradually came to be criticised owing to the constraints of a threedomain model in which economics stands out as the chief domain, the environment is defined in terms of natural. Equality and diversity in the global era paperback august 25, 2002. Inleiding op seyla benhabib and the claims of culture. Equality and diversity in the global era, princeton. Curriculum vita fall 2018 3 bad homburg, germany april 2009 ernst bloch prize of the city of ludhwighaffen, germany for contributions to cultural understanding in a global world.
69 1647 812 75 755 794 1503 1152 1249 1411 521 278 1401 1343 969 1060 1319 1618 721 568 250 1557 387 592 783 1038 417 380 1429 1226 1273 1660 430 256 1059 884 275 908 30 801 1160 58 1400 374